Every Italian restaurant, pizzeria and deli we list, from Taylor Street to Melrose Park. Filter by type and neighborhood.
214 places · 112 neighborhoodsTaylor Street was once the heart of Italian Chicago — by the 1930s it was the largest of roughly twenty Italian enclaves across the city, with Jane Addams estimating around 10,000 Italian immigrants living within a few blocks of her Hull House settlement. That changed in the early 1960s, when Mayor Richard J. Daley quietly steered the neighborhood's land to the University of Illinois. Construction started in 1963 over organized community opposition led by activist Florence Scala, and the campus opened in 1965. Community leaders at the time said the expansion destroyed nearly half the neighborhood outright — the exact number of homes lost is still debated, but the scale of the loss isn't.
Worth being honest about: Taylor Street today is more a dining destination and a name people recognize than a living Italian-American neighborhood. The restaurants and markets that remain are real anchors, not relics, and the annual Taylor Street Little Italy Festival each August keeps the identity alive — but most of the residential community moved on decades ago.
For the real thing, it's arguably stronger in Melrose Park, where Our Lady of Mount Carmel parish has run its feast since 1894 — one of the largest Italian Catholic religious festivals in the country — and in Chicago Heights, where Italian immigrants from Lazio, Sicily and Abruzzo settled to work the steel mills starting in the 1890s. As for who invented Italian beef: nobody's entirely sure. The best-documented story ties it to Italian immigrants working Chicago's stockyards in the early 1900s, not any single inventor — the popular "wedding sandwich" origin story is neighborhood folklore, not settled history.
A TavolaCacio e Pepe
A+ Italian SteakhouseA genuinely strong 4.7+ rating built in under two years, combining Italian cooking with classic steakhouse cuts
AcantoWine Happy Hour · $5.00
AdalinaCacio e Pepe Arancini
Agio Italian BistroA 3,000-Bottle Wine Room
Al's #1 Italian BeefThe Original Gravy-Dipped Beef
Alex's Washington GardensThe First Pizza Ever Served on the North Shore
Alla VitaCrowd-Pleasing Italian
Alto Steakhouse by Fabio VivianiAlto Steakhouse by Fabio Viviani opened in May 2025 on the 17th-floor rooftop of Wind Creek Chicago Southland Casino & Resort, running an Italian steakhouse concept -- Viviani's second entry on this project's map alongside his existing LAGO location in Lake Zurich.
Angelo's Wine BarWednesday Half-Price Wine Bottles + Live Jazz
AnteprimaAnteprima built its reputation on a grilled octopus that stays on the menu year-round -- tender, lemon-kissed, good enough that reviewers mention it before anything else. Housemade pastas round out an Italian menu that doesn't chase trends, and the secluded back patio is a genuine draw, reservable on its own rather than left to walk-in luck, a small detail that sets it apart from most Andersonville patios. It's dinner-only, Wednesday through Sunday, starting at 5pm -- a destination rather than a quick-stop neighborhood spot.
Antico PostoSunday Cavatelli
Ariston Drive InA Magazine-Ranked Gyro
Ascione Bistro - Hyde ParkWeekend Brunch: $18 Bottomless Mimosas
Ascione Bistro SkokieBar Happy Hour: $7 Cocktails & Martinis · $7.00
Autre Monde Cafe & SpiritsWild Boar Bolognese & Cowboy Steak
Bacchanalia RestaurantBYO Wine ($20 Corkage) · ~$20 corkage
Bar RomaThe lasagna with bolognese is the reliable order, and the chocolate lava cake is the dessert worth saving room for even after a heavy meal.
Bar SienaHappy Hour: $9 Espresso Martinis + $3 Arancini · $3-12
Bar Siena North ShoreDaily Happy Hour
Bar TuttoThe prosciutto croissant and a dark-chocolate-filled bomboloni in the morning, then an aperitivo switch to Aperol/Campari cocktails and a deep European wine list by late afternoon -- from a Top Chef winner's all-day European cafe concept.
Bari FoodsThe Italian Sub with Homemade Hot Giardiniera
Barraco'sA full Italian menu (pasta, steaks, seafood) alongside pizza and 24 beers on tap, in an 8,000-square-foot space with a banquet room for 100 -- a regional chain's first real Chicago location.
Barraco's - Orland ParkBarraco's opened this Orland Park location in June 2023, in the former Traverso's building that had run for about 50 years before closing in December 2021 -- a real changing-of-the-guard moment for that specific address. This is a second location of the same family business already on this project's map at Mount Greenwood, dating back to 1980.
Bella Luna CafeBella Luna Cafe has run as an old-school Italian neighborhood restaurant in River North since 1988, the kind of place that predates most of the trendier concepts that have since filled in around it downtown. It picked up a 'Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives' feature along the way, a reasonable sign that Guy Fieri's crew found something worth filming in a menu that's stayed consistent for nearly four decades. Details beyond that are limited, so call ahead before making a special trip.
Bella MiaSteaks and Chops Alongside Its Pasta
Bella Via RistoranteHandmade Pastas & North Shore Wine List
Bob-O's Hot DogsBob-O's Hot Dogs started as a hot dog trailer and cart before expanding to a second location on Milwaukee Avenue -- both ABC7's Hungry Hound and Steve Dolinsky's Top 5 have independently ranked its Italian beef #1 in the city, with the homemade giardiniera called out as the real standout.
Bruna's RistoranteThe sausage and peppers are simple and properly done, the kind of dish that's kept this Pilsen spot a neighborhood favorite for years.
Buona - KildeerOriginal Slow-Roasted Italian Beef
Buona - StreetervilleThis Streeterville Buona is a notable exception for a chain otherwise built entirely around the suburbs -- it's the only Buona location actually inside Chicago city limits. The menu is the standard Buona lineup: Italian beef dipped to order, Italian sausage, the beef-and-sausage combo, meatball and pepper-and-egg sandwiches, thin-crust pizza, and Chicago-style hot dogs, in a 75-seat dining room with outdoor seating in warmer months.
Cafe LucciBrothers Bobby and Augie Arifi have run Cafe Lucci in Glenview since 1995 -- Bobby oversees the dining room and wine list, while self-taught chef Augie, known as "The Mad Chef," runs an eclectic Italian kitchen that pulls from multiple regions rather than one region's cooking. A genuine brothers-run operation, not a single-owner restaurant with a family-sounding name. The motto painted across their own promotional material is "Good Food, Good Wine, Good People," and regulars skew toward North Shore locals and nearby office workers who treat it as a standing lunch spot, alongside Chicago diners who drive out for weekends and special occasions. The building has real range for a suburban storefront: a dedicated wine room set up for intimate tastings for up to 12, and a private upper-level room that handles groups of 20 to 70. The food backs it up -- OpenTable's own aggregate sits around 4.6 stars across roughly 2,200 diner reviews, with burrata, cacio e pepe, eggplant parm, and a notably moist tiramisu/chocolate cake drawing repeat praise, plus a full vegetarian menu that's rarer than it should be at an old-school Italian spot.
Caffè OlivaLakefront Resort Vibe
Calabria ImportsDaily Sandwich Special ($10, Chips + Drink Included) · $10
CampagnolaHandmade Pastas: Bolognese, Tagliatelle & Diavolo · $25.00
Capri by GigiMama Capri's Own Family Recipes
Capri of Willow SpringsHomemade Rigatoni Vita Mia · $26.95
Capriccio Artisan Pizza & CoffeeCapriccio Artisan Pizza & Coffee brought real Roman-style pizza to Lincoln Square in March 2025, and the chef behind it, Guillermo Paolisso, earned the credibility the hard way -- he grew up in Italy working on dough and fermentation technique, then spent time as executive chef right next door at Artango Bar & Steakhouse (id 209) before striking out with his own place. The pizza list runs Rossa, Bianca, Margherita and Funghi alongside the namesake Capriccio pie (prosciutto di Parma, arugula), plus focaccia sandwiches, salads and bakery items for the daytime crowd, and it pours La Colombe coffee to round out the all-day format implied by the name. It's a legitimately different register of pizza than the deep-dish and tavern-style options that dominate most Chicago neighborhoods.
Carm's Beef and Italian IceMeal Combos ($16.99) · $16.99
Chicago Prime Italian SteakhouseHappy Hour: $7 Bites & Drinks
Ciao Baby!A 13-Table, No-Reservations Italian Spot
Ciccio MioCarbonara & Truffle Bucatini
Club LagoPizza Bread
Club LuckyThe Killer Martini with Blue Cheese-Stuffed Olives
Coda di VolpeVera Pizza Napoletana-Certified Pies
Conte Di Savoia$5-$8 Italian Sandwiches
Coppolillo's Italian SteakhouseCoppolillo's Italian Steakhouse is a sister concept to Rosebud Steakhouse-Wheeling, both run by the same CHC Restaurant Group (which also has a Crown Point, Indiana location, out of this project's scope) -- an Italian spin on the steakhouse format rather than a straightforward chophouse.
Cucina ParadisoA 30-year fixture in downtown Oak Park as of 2025 -- long enough to have outlasted most of the restaurants that opened around it, and still turning out new dishes, like a chicken pistachio plate that put a nut-crusted spin on the usual red-sauce playbook. It sits steps from the Green Line's Oak Park stop and under half a mile from the Metra station, which makes it a real option for a dinner that doesn't require a car. Reservations run through Tock now rather than a phone call, a small modernization for a restaurant old enough to remember when that wasn't how it worked.
Da Baffone Cucina ItalianaDa Baffone Cucina Italiana opened in 2010 on downtown Crystal Lake's Main Street, run by Camille and Dominic Giangrande together with her brother-in-law and their three sons -- a genuinely multi-generational family operation in a 60-seat room.
DaisiesTajarin
Davanti EnotecaAperitivo Happy Hour · $8.00
Davanti Enoteca - Western SpringsBrunch
Dave's Italian KitchenLasagna con Amore ($15.50) · $15.50
Deerfield Italian KitchenChicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala & Kitchen Special Pizza
Del Rio RestaurantVeal Del Rio
DeNucci's - HinsdaleDeNucci's Hinsdale is the third location of the Italian-American mini-chain, taking over the former Il Poggiolo space under Ballyhoo Hospitality with the same eggplant parm, veal marsala, branzino piccata, and cacio e pepe playbook as its sister locations. It opened takeout-only in December before moving to full service in January 2026.
DeNucci's - Lincoln ParkTavern-Style Pizza Days
Di PescaraBar Happy Hour: $5 Beer & $10 Di Double · $5.00
Dimmi DimmiSlagel Farms Sausage Orecchiette
Don Walker's Sandwich CenterDon Walker's Sandwich Center has run as a family-owned Aurora sandwich shop for more than 50 years, known specifically for its Italian beef in a city that doesn't get nearly as much Italian-beef attention as Chicago proper.
Donny G's Ristorante & BarFamily-Style Italian/Greek Dining
Dukes Drive-InDukes Drive-In relocated here, inside a Gas N Wash, after its original Bridgeview location -- open 44 years -- closed in August 2019. Bill Humphrey, son-in-law of founder Bud Dukes, reopened it in Mokena using the same suppliers, carrying the recipe forward rather than letting it end with the old building.
Eataly ChicagoEataly Chicago opened in December 2013 as the largest location the Italian marketplace chain had in the US at the time, taking over the old ESPN Zone space with enough square footage to fit a full grocery hall, a wine shop, a cooking school, and several separate sit-down and counter-service eateries under one roof. That scale is still the whole pitch: you can grab fresh pasta and imported olive oil for home, then eat a full meal without leaving the building, something no single River North restaurant can offer. Two of its original internal concepts haven't survived -- Baffo, the ground-floor fine-dining room, closed back in 2016, and a rooftop-style patio concept has since closed too -- but the core marketplace itself has kept running regardless, which says something about the format's staying power even as individual experiments inside it come and go. There's no single discount or special that makes sense here, since it's a dozen different food experiences bundled into one address, not one restaurant with one deal.
Ed & Joe's Restaurant & PizzeriaEd & Joe's Restaurant & Pizzeria runs thin-crust pizza with genuinely odd signature toppings -- taco pizza, cheeseburger pizza -- alongside live acoustic music two nights a week, an Italian-American format that leans into novelty rather than tradition for its specials.
Elina'sSilvio's Meatballs
Ella's Italian Pub - ElmhurstHalf-Price Pizza Sunday · 50% off
Erie CafeKey Lime Pie
Fabulous Freddie's Italian EateryFabulous Freddie's Italian Eatery built its name on breaded and char steak sandwiches alongside Italian beef served in 'regular' and 'gargantuan' sizes -- WBEZ has featured it, which is a real step up from the average neighborhood beef stand's press coverage.
Figo Wine BarPrivate Wine Cellar Room
FiorettaThe tableside Caesar salad is a bit of real theater before the meal even starts, and the king crab linguine is the entree that follows through on the promise.
fire + wineSteak Medallions & Half-Price Pasta Night
Fontano's SubsThe Wiseguy Sub
Fontano's Subs - HinsdaleThe Blockbuster Sub
Forno MauriForno Mauri is chef Maurizio Michi's newer Printers Row pizzeria, taking over the former Baird & Warner real estate office space just down the block from his earlier restaurant Sofi (whose current status is genuinely unclear). It's a walk-in-only operation -- no reservations, no takeout, no phone orders -- built entirely around dine-in pizza service. That no-frills, old-world approach to service is as much the identity here as the food itself.
Fox's Beverly PubSouth Side Irish Parade Day Corned Beef & Cabbage
Francesca's AmiciFrancesca's Amici is a distinct sister location in the wider Mia Francesca restaurant group's Elmhurst outpost -- same family of restaurants already on this project's map at other addresses, but its own standalone kitchen and room here.
Francesca's FamigliaA real confirmed happy hour (Mon-Thu, 3:30-6pm) at the Barrington outpost of the established Mia Francesca restaurant group.
Francesca's IntimoRustic Trattoria Fare & Weekend Brunch
Francesca's on 95thA real confirmed happy hour (Mon-Thu, 3:30-6pm) at the Oak Lawn outpost of the established Mia Francesca restaurant group.
Francesca's VicinatoFrancesca's Vicinato runs a Roman, Tuscan, and Umbrian Italian menu in Palos Park -- part of the wider Mia Francesca/Scott Harris restaurant group that already has several sister locations on this project's map, but this exact one hadn't been added yet.
Francesco's Hole in the WallLively Authentic Italian
Franco's RistoranteFranco's Ristorante is the Armour Square neighborhood's go-to for a thick, roasted pork chop -- the dish locals mention first, alongside handmade gnocchi and meatballs that put it a notch above a generic red-sauce joint. A full bar and fresh salads and seafood round out the menu, and a Grilled Chicken on Ciabatta has become the default lunch order for anyone not committing to a full dinner. It's a straightforward neighborhood Italian spot, the kind built on consistency rather than reinvention.
Franconello's Italian RestaurantFranconello's gives Beverly's Western Avenue strip a straightforward sit-down Italian option amid the stretch's many Irish pubs -- generous, old-school portions of red-sauce classics rather than anything trying to reinvent the genre. It's the kind of neighborhood Italian place built for a reliable family dinner rather than a food-forward night out; call ahead if your group is bigger than four.
Frangella Italian MarketMeatball Subs and Homemade Lasagna
Frankie's Touch of Italy Pizzeria40-Plus Years of Family Pizza Recipes
Frannie's Beef & CateringFrannie's Beef & Catering was founded in 1991 by Vincent DiVencenzo Sr. and is now run by his sons Russ and Vince -- the Illinois House even passed a resolution marking its 30th anniversary in 2019, a genuinely unusual honor for a neighborhood beef stand. The Friday-only egg-and-pepper sandwich is a real, scarce-on-purpose specialty.
Frasca Pizzeria & Wine BarThe Wrightwood salad and the arancini are the two orders people default to, and neither one has let them down yet.
Freddy'sPizza, Arancini & Gelato
Galati's Italian Restaurant and PizzeriaA Real On-site Vegetable Garden Feeding the Kitchen
Gia MiaHappy Hour: Half-Off Small Plates
Gia Mia - WheatonGia Mia - Wheaton is actually the original flagship -- opened in 2015 by founder chef Brian Goewey, with the Lombard location already on this project's map a later sister restaurant, not the other way around. Wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza anchors a menu that also runs pasta, small plates, and seafood out of a real scratch kitchen.
Giacomo's Italian RestaurantA Des Plaines Italian Hidden Gem
Gianni's CafeA Real Seafood Bar: Oysters, Clams, Calamari
Gianni's Ristorante & PizzeriaListed for Years in the Village's Own Restaurant Guide
Giardino Trattoria & PizzeriaGiardino Trattoria & Pizzeria runs a garden-inspired Italian menu on Aurora's downtown restaurant row along River Street, a block that's become a real dining destination rather than just a drive-through downtown.
Gibsons ItaliaRoman Fried Artichokes
Gio's Cafe & DeliGio's Cafe & Deli is a long-running Bridgeport fixture -- Chicagoist was already covering it as a neighborhood favorite back in 2005 and again in 2011, and it's still name-checked on The Infatuation's current Bridgeport guide today. It's the kind of Italian deli-cafe that earns its reputation through two decades of consistency rather than any single signature dish.
Gioacchino's Pizza and Restaurant'Best of the West' Thick-Crust Pizza
GiocoGioco runs a broad authentic-Italian menu in the South Loop -- handmade pastas, prime steaks, fresh seafood and wood-fired thin-crust pizzas covering most of the genre's range in one room. A past chef era brought dishes like braised duck with house-made pappardelle and a whole roasted branzino, giving it a slightly more ambitious streak than a standard neighborhood red-sauce spot. It's been a South Loop fixture long enough to have been through at least one documented chef and menu refresh.
Goat & Vine Restaurant + WineryAn on-site winery, a 'buy 2 entrees get a free bottle of wine' deal, and a $6-cocktail weekday happy hour at a 4.7-star Bolingbrook restaurant.
Harry Caray's Italian Steakhouse - River NorthChicken Vesuvio
Himmel'sHimmel's tells its own history on the menu -- 15 years as the Italian spot Pizza D.O.C. before a pivot into German cooking left a genuine hybrid behind rather than a total reinvention. Hofbrau pours from its own draft system alongside a pork tenderloin with spatzle and red cabbage that's become the kitchen's real signature, plus a pork shank with mushroom gravy sized for serious hunger. The old pizza and pasta haven't fully disappeared, which makes this one of Lincoln Square's few places where a German main and an Italian pizza can land on the same table without anyone blinking.
House Of CakesCheese Sticks & Paczki
Ichi by TorinoICHI by Torino is the fast-casual, counter-service half of a two-restaurant pairing in Wilmette -- bento boxes, onigiri, donburi, and bao built for quick pickup rather than a sit-down meal, with the kitchen leaning on what the business describes as premium, fresh ingredients and a genuinely family-friendly setup. The full ramen and sushi experience lives next door under the sister name Torino Ramen, whose own site headlines it as "North Shore's Best Ramen & Sushi Restaurant" -- though the site itself doesn't name the specific poll or publication behind that claim, so the superlative reads as the restaurant's own branding rather than an independently sourced award. Large dine-in parties get steered over to Torino Ramen, while ICHI stays focused on the grab-and-go side of the menu. It's open seven days, 11:30am to 8pm most of the week and until 7pm on Sundays.
Ignotz's RistoranteChicken Vesuvio
Il CarciofoCarciofo alla Giudia
Il MilaneseIl Milanese built its name on housemade pasta, and The Infatuation's review backs that up as the real reason to go -- even while flagging that the sauces can be inconsistent, with a snoozy tomato version or an overly rich porcini cream occasionally overshadowing good noodles underneath. It opened in North Center in 2018 as part of a small wave of new Italian spots that year, and it's kept a steady local following since, the kind of neighborhood Italian place that doesn't need a tasting menu or a sommelier to justify a weeknight dinner.
Il PorcellinoBaked Burrata Lasagna
Il SognoIl Sogno pairs a rooftop bar with a full Italian restaurant on the same block as this round's other Hale Street additions -- a genuinely different building and address from its neighbors, not an overlapping listing.
Italian VillageCity's Oldest Italian Restaurant
J.P. Graziano GroceryThe Mr. G Sub · $13.50
Jay's BeefJay's Beef started as a trailer and has since celebrated its 50th anniversary -- bright orange-red peppers instead of the usual drab green, a crunchy house giardiniera, and a frozen cheesecake dessert called the 'Wunder Bar' are the three things that keep coming up in coverage.
Jenny's Steak and BanquetsThe sausage mostaccioli is the classic order, old-school Italian-American comfort food done the way it's supposed to be.
Johnnie's BeefItalian Beef, Hot & Dipped
La Barra - RiversideAward-Winning Pizza and Italian Small Plates
La ScarolaGrilled Octopus
La Sorella di FrancescaLa Sorella di Francesca occupies Naperville's old City Hall building with a well-established Italian menu -- the kind of address that gives a restaurant real civic-history weight before the food even arrives.
La VillaA family-owned Chicago pizza institution for over 50 years (founded 1971 or 1972, sources differ by a year), still run by owner Christina on the original ovens. Full bar with live music Thursday through Saturday, plus an attached banquet hall.
La Zingara Trattoria25-Plus Years in Arlington Heights
Labriola$3 sliders, $5 drafts and cocktails, and $8 giant Aperol spritzes during the Mon-Fri 3-6pm bar happy hour
LAGO by Fabio VivianiA Genuine Celebrity-Chef Steakhouse
Legno by SuparossaThe Cirrincione family's reinvention of their longtime Suparossa space into an Italian gastropub -- wood-burning Neapolitan pizzas, handmade pasta, and small plates like arancini and calamari in a room with exposed brick and a visible wood-fired oven. A Northwest Side option with real technique behind it, not just a neighborhood red-sauce standby.
Louie's RestaurantBroasted 4-Piece Chicken Dinner · $8.99
Lucca's Pizzeria & RistoranteLucca's Pizzeria & Ristorante has run in La Grange since 2001, a straightforward Italian-American pizzeria still active enough to show up on current delivery-app listings two decades in. Delivery runs through ChowNow, Postmates, and Uber Eats, and the restaurant also offers gift cards.
Luke's Italian BeefHall-of-Fame Italian Beef
MacelloHappy Hour: Half-Price Appetizers
Mama D'sMama D's bills its homemade Italian beef as a top-10 contender in a city full of serious competition for that title -- a bold claim backed up by a 4.6-star rating across 600-plus UberEats reviews.
Mambo ItalianoNightly Rotating Specials
Mamma Maria's Pizzeria & Ristorante40 Years of Real Local History
Mario's Italian LemonadeThere's no sign, no seats, and definitely no website -- just a walk-up window on Taylor Street that has been shaving Italian ice since long before "artisanal" was a word anyone used about dessert. Mario's rotates through a dozen-ish flavors a day -- lemon, peach, black raspberry, watermelon, chocolate, piña colada -- scooped into paper cups for a few bucks apiece. It's open from May 1 through mid-September, and the owner has kept that closing date tied to his father's memory for decades, which is the kind of detail that tells you this isn't a chain testing a concept. Lines form on warm nights the way they have for generations. Don't go looking for a happy hour or a coupon code -- the whole point of Mario's is that it never needed one.
Mart Anthony's Italian RestaurantThe Chicken Vesuvio is the classic order, and the house-made chocolate cake at the end is not a formality — finish the meal properly.
Mia FrancescaAperitivo Hour: $10 Fried Roman Artichokes + $12 Manhattans · $8-12
Mia FrancescaAperitivo Hour: $10 Aperol Spritz + $9 Truffle Arancini · $8-12
Mino's ItalianPolished Date-Night Italian
Mockingbird Bar + GardenAn East Dundee Wood-Fired Farm-to-Table Kitchen
MonteverdeAcclaimed Handmade Pasta
Moretti's - Fox LakeAward-Winning Pizza
Moretti's - Hoffman EstatesAn Award-Winning Pizza Patio in Hoffman Estates
Moretti's Ristorante and PizzeriaDaily Food Deals / $12 Lunch Special · $12.00
Mr Benny's Steak & LobsterThe Shrimp DeJonghe is a genuine old-school specialty, and the bread pudding at the end is exactly the kind of finish a family-run steakhouse should have.
Mr. BeefThe Real 'Original Beef of Chicagoland'
MunnoThe Circo Massimo pizza and the lasagna are both worth ordering, and the fact that this only opens Wednesday through Thursday makes getting a table feel like an event.
NeotecaA Brick-oven Pizza
Novi's BeefItalian Beef & Sausage Combo
Orso's Italian RestaurantOrso's has been serving straightforward Italian-American red-sauce classics on Wells Street for over 40 years, which in a neighborhood that turns over restaurants every few seasons counts as an institution. Rigatoni paisano and a 14-inch pizza anchor the menu, and it's the kind of place families have been going to for decades rather than a reservation anyone's fighting for online. No happy hour or coupon here -- Orso's trades on consistency, not promotions.
Osteria LanghePiedmontese Regional Cuisine
Osteria OttimoTripAdvisor's Top-rated Restaurant in Orland Park
Ovvio Italian TavernaMezze Lumache alla Vodka
Palermo's 95th Fine Italian CuisineSweet-Sauce Pizza
Paola's Delights BakeryCornetti
Papa Joe's of Orland ParkPapa Joe's of Orland Park runs an Italian-steak-seafood-pizza menu that's hard to pin to one cuisine, with Chicken Tetrazzini as the dish that keeps coming up and a yearly spot at Taste of Orland Park as a real civic fixture.
Pasta D'Arte Trattoria ItalianaTuesday BYOB · $0 corkage
Pasta FreshHouse-Made Ravioli
Pasta Veneta Italian RestaurantSpaghetti with Caviar & White Truffle
Pat's Pizza & RistoranteTavern-Style Thin Crust Sausage Pizza
Peanut Park TrattoriaPeanut Park Trattoria earned a spot on Chicago Magazine's Top Restaurants list in 2022, a notable nod for a Little Italy spot in a neighborhood thick with decades-old red-sauce institutions. It leans dinner-only, opening at 4pm every day it's open, which points toward a more focused, evening-driven trattoria experience than an all-day Taylor Street classic.
Pelago CafeA Brand-New Family-Run Italian Cafe
Pete's Red HotsItalian Beef & Chicago Dog
Petterino'sWeekday Bar Happy Hour + Theater-Ticket Discount · $1-9
Piacere Mio - UptownPiacere Mio brought its Forest Park Italian-country-cooking formula into the city with this Uptown location, built around regional-Italian dishes like rigatoni rustica and a chicken milanese rather than a standard red-sauce menu. It's earned a strong local reputation fast, the kind of rating that makes a relatively new Uptown opening worth seeking out specifically. Hours are inconsistent across listings, so it's worth confirming before a visit.
Piccolo Buco - NapervilleNeapolitan-style red, yellow, and white pizzas paired with Cooper's Hawk's own wine program at a dedicated tasting bar -- the winery's pizza-and-pasta concept in only its second U.S. location.
Piccolo SognoThe back patio is hidden along Halsted, and once you've found it, it becomes the answer to every "somewhere quiet" request.
PinstripesHappy Hour: $5-$10 Drinks & Bites
Pizza Capri - Hyde ParkPizza Capri's Hyde Park outpost covers the straightforward pizza-and-Italian-staples ground that the neighborhood's more specialized restaurants don't bother with -- thin-crust and Chicago-style pies, salads, pastas, the kind of reliable delivery order a campus-adjacent neighborhood depends on. It's one location of a small local chain rather than a singular destination, which is exactly the point: dependable, available, and easy to order from on a weeknight.
Pizza House - ZionThe Italian Beef
Pizzeria PortofinoBar Harbor Mussels
Pompei1909 Family-Run Bakery
Pop's Italian Beef & Sausage45th Anniversary Deal
Positano RistorantePositano Ristorante is a sister location to an original restaurant of the same name in Oakbrook Terrace, running a straightforward Italian dinner menu with hours confirmed directly on OpenTable. The restaurant's own OpenTable listing advertises weekly, seasonally inspired specials, though the exact current rotation isn't posted publicly.
Positano Ristorante (Oakbrook Terrace Original)Positano Ristorante's Oakbrook Terrace location is the original, running in a strip mall for roughly five years before the already-on-file Wheaton sister restaurant opened under the same name and menu. Family owned and operated since 2020, per the restaurant's own Toast ordering page. Catering and private-event inquiries go through its own email.
Posto 31Short Rib Gnocchi
Quartino RistoranteVeal Meatballs
Rex Italian FoodsHouse-Made Italian Meats and Lasagna
Riccardo EnotecaExtensive By-the-Glass Wine List
Ricobene'sBreaded Steak Sandwich + Chicken Vesuvio
Riviera Italian Imported FoodsRiviera Italian Imported Foods is a family-run Italian grocery and deli that's operated for more than 60 years under the Pugliese family -- made-to-order subs including Italian beef, alongside in-house cured meats like soppressata and capocollo that most beef-stand-only competitors don't bother making themselves.
RoccoVino's Italian Restaurant by Vince'sA 50-Year Harlem Avenue Institution
Roma's Italian Beef, Sausage & PizzaRoma's Italian Beef, Sausage & Pizza is a Vienna Beef Hall of Fame honoree on Cicero Avenue, cash/Venmo/Zelle only -- the kind of no-frills operation that earns its reputation strictly on the sandwich, not the storefront.
Rosario's Pizzeria and RistoranteFamily-Run Since 1976, the Area's Best
Rose MaryGreat Date Night
Rosebud DeerfieldFriday Happy Hour
Rosebud LemontA Real Rosebud Restaurants-Group Location
Rosebud on RushRosebud on Rush has stayed Chicago's go-to power-dining address long enough that a 2025 feature still calls it the city's ultimate business-lunch-and-big-deal-dinner destination. The house-made pasta earns real praise from AAA's own inspectors, alongside a roasted chicken Vesuvio (red potatoes, peas, white wine sauce) and an orecchiette with sausage and broccolini finished in garlic and olive oil. Portions run generously large, business casual is the expected dress code, and the overall vibe leans formal-but-approachable rather than fussy fine dining.
Rosebud Taylor StreetRosebud's Taylor Street flagship is the one that started the whole Chicago Italian-restaurant dynasty back in 1976, and after a stretch operating as a private event space only, it reopened to walk-in diners again in summer 2025. It's the original red-sauce institution the rest of the group's locations (including the Streeterville outpost on Rush St) trace back to, sitting right in the heart of Little Italy near the University of Illinois at Chicago campus.
RPM ItalianMama DePandi's Pomodoro anchors a rotating lineup of more than a dozen daily housemade pastas -- ask what's fresh that day rather than defaulting to the menu's safest pick.
Salerno's Pizza & CateringSalerno's Pizza & Catering runs a straightforward strip-mall Italian menu -- pizza, calzones, panzerotti, pasta -- the kind of neighborhood spot that doesn't need a design concept to keep a 4.5-star delivery rating.
Salutos Pizza & PastaSalutos Pizza & Pasta has served northern Lake County since 1990 by its own account, known for homemade pasta and a secret-recipe salad dressing -- a real neighborhood Italian spot rather than a chain riding on the Gurnee outlet-mall foot traffic.
Saranello'sA Genuinely From-Scratch Italian Ristorante
Scafuri BakeryScafuri Bakery has run as a family operation on Taylor Street since 1904, with one real gap -- it closed in 2007 before reopening in 2013 -- and sfogliatelle and Italian cakes are still the reason people specifically seek it out on a street full of Italian-American food history.
Scatchell's Beef & PizzaItalian Beef Since 1953
Siam PastaDaily Lunch Special
Siena TavernHappy Hour Pasta + Wine · $12.00
SottoPasta alla Norma
Tempesta MarketThe B. Franklin sandwich is the reason for the trip, and the minestrone soup is the reason to come back on a cold day.
The Original Nottoli & SonThe Beef Combo & Italian Sub
The PatioThe Patio has run under the same family since 1948 in Little Italy, and Time Out calls its Italian beef-and-sausage combo as legendary as its hot dogs -- a longtime cop hangout where the food has outlasted the neighborhood's many changes around it.
The RadicleThe Return of the $10 Cocktail
Tony's Italian BeefA well-regarded Italian beef with a surprisingly deep sandwich menu beyond it -- a breaded steak, Greek chicken, and a Sicilian steak with egg all show up alongside the beef.
Tony's Italian Deli & SubsThe Sicilian meatball sub (featured in Midwest Living magazine) and homemade cannoli at a family deli so embedded in Edison Park it got its own honorary street name in 2018.
Topo Gigio RistoranteVeal Saltimbocca & Squid Ink Pasta
TortelloFresh Pasta Destination
Trattoria PorrettaSaturday Drink & Pizza Package
Tre DitaMonday Lasagna Verde
Tre Sorelle RistoranteTre Sorelle Ristorante picked up the thread of Mancini's -- Al Mancini's original Italian spot opened in 1976 and moved to this Oak Park address in 1995 before being sold in 2014 and eventually closing -- reopening under a new name in December 2019. Sunday live jazz has become one of its regular draws.
Tufano's Vernon Park TapLemon Chicken & Pasta Fagioli
Tuscany on TaylorHappy Hour + Tuscany Tuesdays
VAI's Italian Inspired Restaurant Kitchen + BarSpicy Chicken Tortellacci
Vinny's Clam BarA 4.6-Star Seafood-and-Italian Favorite
VoidSpaghetti Uh-O's
Volare Ristorante ItalianoVolare Risotti al Nero (Squid Ink Seafood Risotto) · $40.00
Za Za'sThe 'Best Italian Food' Distinction
Zia's SocialWood-fired pizzas and Zia's Trattoria classics served inside a former brewpub's preserved wood-burning oven and bow-truss ceilings
Nothing matches that combination yet. Try another neighborhood or type.
It's still called that, but it's mostly a dining and cultural identity today rather than a residential Italian-American neighborhood — most of the original community moved on after the University of Illinois at Chicago's campus construction in the 1960s.
Mayor Richard J. Daley directed the land to the University of Illinois in the early 1960s; construction began in 1963 despite organized community opposition, and the campus opened in 1965. Community leaders at the time said the project destroyed nearly half the neighborhood.
Melrose Park has a real, long-running Italian-American community, anchored by Our Lady of Mount Carmel parish's annual feast, held every year since 1894.
There's no single confirmed inventor. The most credible origin story ties it to Italian immigrants working Chicago's stockyards in the early 1900s; the popular "wedding sandwich" tale is folklore, not documented history.
Dish Picker lands on one real special for you. Send it to the group if you like it.
→ 🏆Ranked by real ratings, member votes, and our own editorial judgment.
→ 📍Tell us and we'll check it out.
→