Sign In

Sign in to upvote deals and save your favorite spots.

or
or use your phone

Host a Party Here

Invite friends to meet up at Milly's Pizza in the Pan — get a shareable link, no guest accounts needed.

View Full Business Page →

Milly's Pizza in the Pan

Super GemWest Town · Pizza Community-sourced, unverified
📍 925 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60622
Photo: Milly's Pizza In The Pan- West Town via Google

Milly's Pizza in the Pan is what happens when a guy who ate a lot of Burt's Place decides to stop eating and start making.

Tourist Friendly
Super GemChicago Exclusive Gem$$
The No Comply, nduja, ricotta and saba on that burnt-cheese pan crust. Order online early, because pies sell out.
📈 Scores in the top 99% of Chicago Exclusive Gems on ChicagoSpecials.com

Robert Maleski, a longtime restaurant server, opened Milly's in 2020 and named it after his grandmother Emily, the one who taught him to cook, while the pies themselves are a tribute to Burt Katz and his Chicago pan pizza: a thick, buttery crust baked until the cheese around the edge caramelizes into a dark, crunchy ring that is the whole point. The business started as a ghost kitchen, and Robert still makes only a limited number of pizzas each day, so the move is to order online ahead or call to check what is left before you show up. The menu reads like a record collection, with pies named No Comply (nduja, ricotta and saba syrup), Leandoer 10 (crème fraîche, roasted mushrooms, pistachio and pesto), Tom's Killing (vodka sauce, pepperoni, everything bagel spice and chili crunch) and a Detroit-style Killtaker.

Tens run about $25 to $29, fourteens $30 to $37, and they come uncut unless you ask, so the crust stays crisp. Seating at this Ashland Avenue shop is first come, first served, open Wednesday through Sunday from 4 to 8pm, with a second Milly's on Broadway in Lakeview.

📸 Recent on Instagram
📸 See more of Milly's Pizza in the Pan

Specials at Milly's Pizza in the Pan

(2)

Hours

Mon-TueClosed
Wed-Sun4PM-8PM
📅 Reservations not available 🥡 Takeout available 📞 (224) 809-7192 ✉️ Email

Amenities & accessibility

🚶Walk-in only
🥡Takeout available
❔Wheelchair access: unverified

Location

Photos

No photos yet — be the first to add one.

Have a photo from a recent visit? — customers and business owners both welcome.

Similar spots nearby

Know about a deal here that's not listed? Add it below — we'll verify and publish it.

to suggest a special.

Thanks for stopping by
Loading a Chicago fact…
Advertisement
Own or manage Milly's Pizza in the Pan? Claim this listing to verify your hours and add real photos.
Illustration of a tavern bar counter at night with a cheeseburger, a shot and a beer, and one empty stool
📰 The Scoop

Where Anthony Bourdain Actually Ate in Chicago

18 stops from his three Chicago episodes that you can still walk into tonight, three you just missed, and a map of all of them.

Read the Story →
Chicago's Best — ranked pizza, burgers, BBQ, and more
🏆 Chicago's Best

Pizza, Burgers, BBQ & More — Ranked

The Chicago Specials Score: member votes plus our own editorial judgment, updated as new spots earn their place.

See the Rankings →
Chicago Events — festivals, parades, concerts and more, curated month by month
📅 Events

Festivals, Parades & Concerts — All Year Long

Every real, verified Chicago event worth planning around — browse month by month, from this weekend to next summer.

See What's On →