Name: Pie-Eyed Pizzeria
Address: 1111 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL, 60642
Telephone: 312-243-3735
Price range: $

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

Super GemRiver West · Pizza (deep dish & slice) Community-sourced, unverified

📍 1111 W Chicago Ave, Chicago, IL 60642

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria has been a River West fixture since 2004, run by brothers Evan and Ian Muellner with their mother Sandy still making the meat toppings twice a week — the kind of family-operation detail that explains why a 21-year-old neighborhood pizzeria just landed at #3 on Fodor's Travel's list of the best pizza slices in the entire United States for 2026, on top of Food Network separately naming it Illinois' best slice in 2025.

Fodor's Travel's #3 pizza slice in the entire US (2026) and Food Network's best slice in Illinois (2025), plus a rotating monthly specialty pizza

The deep dish and slice program both hold up, and Time Out specifically calls out the giardiniera as the move.

The kitchen keeps things interesting with a rotating Pizza-of-the-Month program — 'The Zombie,' 'The Frankensteiner' with Peppadew peppers — available across regular, gluten-free, or vegan crusts, so the regulars always have a reason to come back even after two decades.

Hours

Mon

Wed

Thu11am-11pm; Fri 11am-2am; Sat 12pm-2am; Sun 3pm-10pm; closed Tue

🥡 Takeout unconfirmed 📞 312-243-3735

Amenities & accessibility

❔Takeout: unverified

❔Wheelchair access: unverified

Location

🧭 Apple Maps 📍 Google Maps

Photos

No photos yet — be the first to add one.

Have a photo from a recent visit? — customers and business owners both welcome.

Know about a deal here that's not listed? Add it below — we'll verify and publish it.

to suggest a special.

Think Pie-Eyed Pizzeria deserves Iconic/Notable or Super Gem status? Tell us why.

to nominate a gem.

Keep exploring

Nearby

Full Directory

Explore

Happy Hour

Discover

Read

By Day

By Deal Type

Neighborhoods

Account

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

Specials at Pie-Eyed Pizzeria