Sign In

Sign in to upvote deals and save your favorite spots.

or
or use your phone

View Full Business Page →
The Green Mill Cocktail Lounge's green neon sign glowing above its entrance on Broadway in Chicago
Finds

The Jazz Club Famous For a Capone Legend That Probably Isn't True

Every tour guide points at the same booth and says the same name. The Chicago historian who's actually dug through the paper trail says it almost certainly didn't happen that way — and the real story, involving a slashed throat, a Prohibition raid, and a dead Sunday night in 1986, is better anyway.

By ChicagoSpecials.com · · 5 min read

Walk into the Green Mill on any given night and someone will eventually point you toward a specific booth and tell you Al Capone used to sit there. It's the best-known fact about the place, repeated on mob-history bus tours and first dates alike. It also probably isn't true.

Chicago historian Robert Loerzel, who spent years tracing the club's actual ownership records for a book on its history, found that the room's current layout — the one with that famous booth — didn't exist in its present form until 1935. Capone had already been in federal prison for tax evasion since 1931. The math doesn't work, and historians including Richard Lindberg have called most of the Capone connection outright urban legend. What's not legend: the club really was tied to Chicago's Prohibition-era underworld, just through a different, less cinematic name.

A Roadhouse, a Raid, and a Slashed Throat

📍 Uptown — 4802 N Broadway · See The Green Mill on Chicago Specials →

The building dates to 1907, when it opened as Pop Morse's Roadhouse at the edge of what was then open country north of the city. It went through a string of names over the next two decades — Morse's Cafe & Garden, then the Montmartre Cafe — before a judge ordered it shut down in 1926 for Prohibition violations. It reopened later that year as the New Green Mill Cafe under new ownership reportedly connected to the Chicago Outfit, with Jack "Machine Gun" McGurn, a real Capone associate, taking a piece of it.

The club's most dramatic true story belongs to Joe E. Lewis, its emcee through 1926 and 1927. Lewis left for a better-paying gig at a downtown club, and that November, someone attacked him and slashed his throat badly enough that he nearly lost his ability to speak, let alone perform. Who ordered it, and whether McGurn was really behind it, is still disputed — but the attack itself is well documented, and it became famous decades later as the basis for the 1957 Frank Sinatra film The Joker Is Wild. That film, more than anything else, is where most of today's Capone mythology actually comes from.

From Mob Rumor to Jazz Landmark

The club closed again in December 1927 amid bad business and reopened the following October as Ye Olde Green Mill. It kept going, on and off, through the decades that followed, hosting Billie Holiday, Al Jolson, Charlie Chaplin, and Frank Sinatra himself at various points — the kind of guest list that's real and well documented, unlike the Capone booth. Its current identity as one of the country's longest continuously operating jazz clubs dates to June 19, 1986, when Dave Jemilo took over and has run it ever since.

That same year, on a slow Sunday night meant to fill an empty room, poet Marc Smith brought his weekly reading series to the Green Mill from a smaller Bucktown bar. It's still there: the Uptown Poetry Slam, widely credited as the event that popularized the entire poetry-slam format now performed in cities worldwide, still runs every Sunday at 7PM for $6 — a genuinely stranger and better founding story than anything involving a gangster's booth. The room also shows up, decades later, as one of the real music-venue backdrops in High Fidelity — a much smaller cameo than the Capone legend, but a real one.

The move: Sunday's $6 Uptown Poetry Slam at 7PM is the cheapest, easiest way into the room if you've never been. For the jazz itself, Friday's late jam session (led by Marquis Hill, 1-3:30AM) and Saturday's Righteous Rooster organ trio (until 4AM) both carry a $5 cover after 1AM. Closed one day a year, for Thanksgiving.

Finds is where we go looking for the places that never bought an ad and never needed to. Know a Chicago-area spot that belongs on the next one?

Nominate a Gem →
The Music Box Theatre marquee in Chicago, a real location from High Fidelity
🎬 Field Guide

High Fidelity: Every Real Location, Mapped

The Green Mill is one of several real Wicker Park-area venues this movie actually used — see every real stop, mapped.

Read the Story →
Illustration of a tavern bar counter at night with a cheeseburger, a shot and a beer, and one empty stool
📰 The Scoop

Where Anthony Bourdain Actually Ate in Chicago

18 stops from his three Chicago episodes that you can still walk into tonight, three you just missed, and a map of all of them.

Read the Story →
Chicago's Best — ranked pizza, burgers, BBQ, and more
🏆 Chicago's Best

Pizza, Burgers, BBQ & More — Ranked

The Chicago Specials Score: member votes plus our own editorial judgment, updated as new spots earn their place.

See the Rankings →
Chicago Events — festivals, parades, concerts and more, curated month by month
📅 Events

Festivals, Parades & Concerts — All Year Long

Every real, verified Chicago event worth planning around — browse month by month, from this weekend to next summer.

See What's On →