Most of the places in this series are real survivors — bars that happened to open decades ago and just never closed. Untitled Supper Club is the opposite kind of trick: a room built in 2012, designed from the ground up to feel like it's been hiding since 1920.
There's no actual Prohibition-era history under 111 W. Kinzie St. The unmarked door, the sense that you might be in the wrong place, the feeling of having found something — all of that was the design brief, not an accident of survival. It works anyway.
A Speakeasy Built to Look Discovered
Atomic Hospitality opened the roughly 17,000-square-foot room in River North, with Marc Bushala named as a partner in early coverage, in either 2011 or 2012 depending on the source — press reviews from June 2012 already treated it as an established spot, which points toward 2012 as the more likely year. The entrance sits beneath a CVS, with nothing on the street marking it beyond a plain, unlabeled door. Inside, a wall was built to physically slide open and reveal the room behind it — a bit of literal stagecraft that's stayed part of the concept ever since.
The opening drinks program came from Matthew "Choo" Lipsky and Adam Scholten, leaning into the Prohibition-era cocktail revival that was already picking up across the city by 2012.
A Pandemic Renovation Doubled Down on the Bit
Rather than scale the theatrics back, a later renovation expanded them. The room now runs four named spaces — the Library, the Cabaret, the Back Stage Bar, and the Drawing Room — connected by a 30-foot sliding door that reveals the Cabaret on cue, plus a dedicated room called The Vault built around a serious, now largely shoppable collection of rare whiskey. It's the kind of upgrade that could have tipped into theme-park territory; by most contemporary coverage, it instead sharpened the one thing the room was already good at.
The move: Go for the whiskey program in The Vault if you're the type who reads bottle labels, or just let the room do the work and order off the cocktail list. Either way, look for the plain door under the CVS sign — that's the whole point.
Finds is where we go looking for the places that never bought an ad and never needed to. Know a Chicago-area spot that belongs on the next one?
Nominate a Gem →