Sign In

Sign in to upvote deals and save your favorite spots.

or
or use your phone

View Full Business Page →
A dim Chicago tavern interior with a faded folk-art mural covering one wall, lit by a single pendant light
Finds

The Dive Bar With a Secret Glogg Recipe and a Mural That Allegedly Cries

A Swedish immigrant's tavern has been quietly serving the same mulled wine, under lock-and-key recipe, for 90 years. The current owner also swears the 1950 hunting-party mural on the wall started weeping the day his predecessor died.

By ChicagoSpecials.com · · 4 min read

Most dive bars don't have a signature drink nobody outside the building knows how to make. Simon's Tavern does — and it's been guarding the recipe since before most of Andersonville's other Swedish institutions closed for good.

Simon Lundberg, a Swedish immigrant, ran the place as an illegal basement speakeasy through the back half of Prohibition before it became a legally licensed bar in May 1934. For a neighborhood that was then one of the largest Swedish enclaves in America, it became exactly what a tavern like that was supposed to be: a mecca for the immigrant community living and working around it.

Glogg, Guarded Like a State Secret

📍 Andersonville — 5210 N Clark St · See Simon's Tavern on Chicago Specials →

The signature order is glogg, a Swedish spiced mulled wine, made from a recipe current owner Scott Martin keeps genuinely top-secret — multiple outlets that have asked him directly have come away with no more than a general description. It runs hot through the winter, roughly November into March, and switches to an iced, slushie version once the weather turns, which is less a gimmick than it sounds: this is a 90-year-old Swedish tavern serving a frozen cocktail in July because the regulars expect it by now.

Lundberg ran the tavern until his death, when his son Roy took it over. Sources disagree on exactly when Scott Martin bought it from Roy — one account puts the sale in 1994, another suggests sometime around the 2010s — but everyone agrees on the order: Simon, then Roy, then Martin, the bar's third owner across nine decades on the same Clark Street corner.

The Mural That Started Crying

The other thing people ask about is the mural behind the bar, based on a 1949 photo from the tavern's annual Deer Hunters Ball. In 1950, Simon Lundberg commissioned the painting from Sigurd F. Olson — a name better known today as a nature writer and wilderness preservationist than as a tavern muralist, which makes the connection stranger than it needed to be. Martin says the haunting started with that mural: he believes one of the painted figures is tied to Roy's own romantic history, and that Roy's painted face in the mural changed — he's described it as developing a tear — around the time Roy died. (A few accounts place the party scene itself in the 1960s rather than 1949; we've gone with the date Martin himself has given.) The mural has deteriorated badly enough since that a fan-driven restoration fund is now trying to save it.

The move: Go for the glogg, hot or frozen depending on the season, and budget for cash — this is the kind of tavern where a card reader still feels like a recent addition. The mural's worth a close look while you're at the bar, tear or no tear.

Finds is where we go looking for the places that never bought an ad and never needed to. Know a Chicago-area spot that belongs on the next one?

Nominate a Gem →
Illustration of a tavern bar counter at night with a cheeseburger, a shot and a beer, and one empty stool
📰 The Scoop

Where Anthony Bourdain Actually Ate in Chicago

18 stops from his three Chicago episodes that you can still walk into tonight, three you just missed, and a map of all of them.

Read the Story →
Chicago's Best — ranked pizza, burgers, BBQ, and more
🏆 Chicago's Best

Pizza, Burgers, BBQ & More — Ranked

The Chicago Specials Score: member votes plus our own editorial judgment, updated as new spots earn their place.

See the Rankings →
Chicago Events — festivals, parades, concerts and more, curated month by month
📅 Events

Festivals, Parades & Concerts — All Year Long

Every real, verified Chicago event worth planning around — browse month by month, from this weekend to next summer.

See What's On →