ChicagoChicago will argue about pizza forever and never settle it. Burgers are calmer. There's less tribal warfare, less "well, actually" energy about crust and cut — just a citywide agreement that a great one is worth waiting for, driving for, and occasionally building an entire night around. These six prove it in six different directions: one that turned a no-reservations grind into a national reputation, one that hides a fried egg and togarashi mayo inside a kimchi burger, and one that skips the bun altogether.
A note on the ranking: this list draws on the Chicago Specials Score, our blend of community upvotes and editorial judgment used across the site's Best-Of rankings, cross-checked against what regulars and critics actually say about each spot. It isn't a permanent top six. Menus change, lines get longer or shorter, and we'll update this as the city does.
1. Au Cheval — West Loop
Brendan Sodikoff's Hogsalt diner built its entire reputation on one burger — dijonnaise, housemade pickles, onions, and Kraft American cheese, nothing fussier than that — and it's been called one of the best cheeseburgers in the country by enough outlets that the claim stopped sounding like hype years ago. For a long stretch, the wait was the whole story: two, three, four hours, no way to reserve, no way around it. Au Cheval now takes reservations, which hasn't made it a secret so much as a slightly less punishing one.
The move: Dijonnaise on everything. No substitutions. That's the entire point.
2. Kuma's Corner — Avondale
Every burger here is named after a heavy metal band — order the Metallica, the Iron Maiden, or go deep-cut with the Goblin Cock or the Bongzilla — each one a half-pound patty on a pretzel roll, under album covers and band posters covering every inch of wall. The one non-metal name on the menu, the Kuma Burger itself, comes stacked with bacon, cheddar, and a fried egg. It's popular enough that Avondale now has siblings in Schaumburg and Indianapolis, but the original is still the one where metalheads and burger obsessives show up for the same reason.
The move: Start with the Kuma Burger, then go pick a band you've never heard of for round two.
3. Little Bad Wolf — Edgewater
The Wolf Burger is the order that built this place's reputation, and it's not hard to see why after the first bite. The room backs it up: wolf illustrations nodding to Little Red Riding Hood, industrial bones softened into something cozy, 2000s rock on the speakers instead of whatever ambient playlist most gastropubs default to. There's no reservations, so there's usually a wait, and the rest of the menu wanders past straight American into Mexican- and Asian-inflected bar food — which keeps a second visit from feeling redundant.
The move: No reservations means go hungry and patient, or go on a weeknight and skip the line entirely.
4. bopNgrill — Rogers Park
Two sister locations, on Superior Street and Belmont Avenue, have since closed; this Sheridan Road spot is the one still standing, and it's the original idea in its clearest form. The kimchi fries — nacho cheese, smoked bacon, the owner's mother's kimchi recipe, truffle oil — and the kimchi burger, built around a fried egg and togarashi mayo, are what regulars order first. The bop menu, an updated bibimbap, is there for anyone who wants rice instead of a bun. It takes reservations, which is rare for a burger counter and worth using.
The move: The kimchi fries aren't a side. Treat them as the appetizer round.
5. Smash Jibarito — Paseo Boricua
David Matulac joined the project in 2023, and the pair ran a kitchen residency inside West Town's Desert Hawk Bar starting in 2024 before building out this permanent Paseo Boricua storefront in 2025, in a former Guerrero's Tacos & Pizza space. The idea reinvents the jibarito as a smash burger, with plantain standing in for the bun entirely — and it's holding a 4.8-star rating while doing it.
The move: Seating is limited and there's no public restroom on site, so treat it as a stop on a walk, not a place to camp out.
6. The Drop In — River West
This is a small neighborhood-bar space — don't bring a big group — and the smash burger is the everyday order. But the real move is the $18 burger/shot/beer combo after 10PM, the kind of deal that turns a late night out into a plan instead of an accident.
The move: Go after 10PM and order the combo. That's the whole review.
This is the first entry in an ongoing Guides series — ranked lists across pizza, tacos, BBQ, and whatever else Chicago is quietly best at. Know a burger that should be on the next version of this list, or a spot we got wrong? A father and son read every nomination.
Nominate a Gem →
